https://whitecollarprofessional.com/news-updates/supreme-court-of-india/supreme-court-applies-obc-creamy-layer-ruling-to-pending-cse-2025-allocations White Collar Professional en 2026-11-06T17:19:00.000Z Supreme Court Applies OBC Creamy-Layer Ruling to Pending CSE 2025 Allocations reservation roster allocation, OBC creamy layer criteria, DoPT 2004 letter, 1993 OBC Office Memorandum, CSE 2025 service allocation https://whitecollarprofessional.com/news-updates/supreme-court-of-india/the-supreme-court-upheld-the-delhi-high-court-full-bench-decision-that-the-natio White Collar Professional en 2026-11-06T17:12:00.000Z The Supreme Court upheld the Delhi High Court Full Bench decision that the National Book Trust, India is an instrumentality of the State under Article 12 of the Constitution. The Court found that the Union Government’s control over the Trust’s creation, governing body, executive administration, finances, audit and governing rules was deep and pervasive, rather than merely regulatory. Key Highlights : • The appeal arose from the Delhi High Court Full Bench’s conclusion that the National Book Trust, India (NBT) is ‘State’ within Article 12 of the Constitution. • NBT was established through a Government of India resolution dated 15 June 1957 and reorganised by a further resolution dated 28 September 1962. • Under the Trust’s Rules, the Government appoints the Chairman, nominates members and places representatives of the Ministries of Education, Finance, and Information and Broadcasting in its governing structure. • The Government exercises oversight over the Trust’s executive and financial administration, including its accounts, audit, annual reporting and specified changes to its rules and objects. • The Court held that the Article 12 test depends on the cumulative degree of financial, functional and administrative control; the fact that NBT earns income from publications does not displace pervasive governmental control. • The appeal was dismissed. The Court clarified that Article 12 status does not make NBT a Government department or automatically convert its employees into civil servants. Background : • The legal question was whether NBT, a society/trust rather than a conventional statutory corporation, falls within the expression ‘other authorities’ in Article 12. • The Delhi High Court Full Bench examined NBT independently under the constitutional tests governing governmental instrumentalities and agencies. • The Trust contended that it was not a State authority and relied, among other things, on its legal form and its ability to generate income through publication activities. What Has Changed : • Issue: Whether the National Book Trust, India is ‘State’ within the meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution. • Finding: The form of incorporation or registration is not decisive. A society or trust can fall within Article 12 if the cumulative facts establish that the Government financially, functionally and administratively dominates or pervasively controls it. • Finding: Government involvement in NBT is structural: the Government created the Trust, appoints its Chairman, nominates members to its governing and executive bodies, participates in financial administration, receives annual reports and accounts, and retains oversight over audit and specified amendments to the governing framework. • Finding: Government grants are relevant but not conclusive. Nor does the Trust’s independent revenue from publication sales negate the broader pattern of control. • Clarification: NBT’s Article 12 status attracts the constitutional discipline applicable to State action under Part III. It does not, by itself, make NBT a Government department or confer civil-servant status or all protections under Articles 309, 310 and 311 on its employees. • Outcome: The Supreme Court upheld the Full Bench decision and dismissed the appeal. Who Is Affected : • National Book Trust, India, including its governing and executive bodies. • Persons seeking to enforce fundamental rights against NBT in relation to State action. • Employees and other persons dealing with NBT, subject to the Court’s clarification that Article 12 status does not automatically confer Government-service status. Compliance Action Points : 1. No direct regulatory filing or compliance deadline is prescribed. 2. NBT should account for the constitutional standards governing State action under Part III when exercising its powers and performing its functions. 3. Persons considering proceedings against NBT should distinguish Article 12 status from the separate legal questions governing service conditions and civil-servant protections. Analysis & Impact : • For CA / CS / Tax & Legal Professionals: The decision is relevant to public bodies, societies and government-supported institutions. Article 12 analysis turns on the cumulative structure of control, not merely the entity’s legal form or the proportion of its income derived from grants. • For Businesses & Investors: Limited relevance. The judgment does not concern a commercial transaction or impose a new financial reporting obligation. • For News Readers: The Supreme Court has confirmed that the National Book Trust is a State authority for fundamental-rights purposes because of the Government’s pervasive control over its functioning. • Points to Watch: The Court expressly limited the consequence of the ruling: Article 12 status does not automatically make NBT employees Government servants or extend Articles 309–311 protections. References : • Constitution of India – Article 12: defines ‘State’ for the purposes of Part III, including ‘other authorities’. • Constitution of India – Part III: fundamental rights and constitutional discipline applicable to State action. • Constitution of India – Articles 309, 310 and 311: referred to by the Court to clarify that Article 12 status does not automatically confer civil-servant status or associated service protections. • Ajay Hasia v. Khalid Mujib Sehravardi, (1981) 1 SCC 722: factors for determining whether a body is an instrumentality or agency of the State. • Pradeep Kumar Biswas v. Indian Institute of Chemical Biology: the cumulative test of financial, functional and administrative domination or pervasive control. • Ramana Dayaram Shetty v. International Airport Authority of India: foundational principles concerning State instrumentalities. • Zee Telefilms Ltd. v. Union of India, (2005) 4 SCC 649: public function alone is insufficient to establish Article 12 status. Source & Attribution : Primary source: Supreme Court of India judgment, Civil Appeal No. 14369 of 2015, 2026 INSC 1202, dated 06 November 2026, supplied as the source PDF. The judgment also refers to NBT’s official history and Rules. Disclaimer: This summary is an editorial aid prepared from publicly available information. It is not legal, tax or investment advice. Refer to the original notification, circular, order or report before acting. service record review, uncommunicated adverse remarks, confidential report entries, Rule 42B Pension Rules, Fundamental Rule 56, Chhattisgarh compulsory retirement https://whitecollarprofessional.com/news-updates/supreme-court-of-india/supreme-court-holds-national-book-trust-to-be-state-under-article-12 White Collar Professional en 2026-11-06T16:52:00.000Z Supreme Court Holds National Book Trust to Be State Under Article 12 - Pradeep Kumar Biswas test, pervasive government control, instrumentality of State test, Article 12 Constitution, NBT State authority, National Book Trust Article 12 https://whitecollarprofessional.com/news-updates/supreme-court-of-india/supreme-court-tightens-forest-rights-review-and-oversight-in-tamil-nadu White Collar Professional en 2026-11-06T16:45:00.000Z Supreme Court Tightens Forest Rights Review and Oversight in Tamil Nadu Agasthyamalai landscape, Gram Sabha constitution deadline, silk cotton cultivation forest land, FDST OTFD eligibility, Tamil Nadu forest encroachment, Forest Rights Act 2006 claims https://whitecollarprofessional.com/news-updates/supreme-court-of-india/supreme-court-fixes-twenty-year-schedule-for-himachals-hydel-power-arrears White Collar Professional en 2026-11-06T16:33:00.000Z Supreme Court Fixes Twenty-Year Schedule for Himachal’s Hydel Power Arrears , Punjab Haryana energy supply, ₹420.77 crore capital cost, 7.19 percent hydel entitlement, 13,066 million units, Bhakra Beas power arrears, Himachal Pradesh power share https://whitecollarprofessional.com/news-updates/sebi-scra/sebi-revises-underlying-exposure-limits-for-foreign-exchange-currency-derivative White Collar Professional en 2026-11-05T16:02:00.000Z SEBI Revises Underlying Exposure Limits for Foreign Exchange Currency Derivative Contracts SEBI currency derivatives circular 2026, underlying exposure FX derivatives limit, RBI circular 25 foreign exchange, FPI unhedged position limits INR, SEBI master circular amendment currency pairs https://whitecollarprofessional.com/news-updates/sebi-scra/sebi-master-circular-for-alternative-investment-funds-aifs-summary White Collar Professional en 2026-11-05T15:52:00.000Z SEBI Master Circular for Alternative Investment Funds (AIFs) Summary operational mandates., investments, fund raising, Comprehensive regulatory framework, compilation detailing governance https://whitecollarprofessional.com/news-updates/reserve-bank-of-india/rbi-tightens-rules-for-foreign-exchange-derivative-contracts-and-exposure-limits White Collar Professional en 2026-11-05T16:12:00.000Z RBI Tightens Rules for Foreign Exchange Derivative Contracts and Exposure Limits RBI forex derivative rules, A.P. DIR Series Circular 25, foreign exchange exposure threshold, INR currency derivatives, forex hedging rules, RBI https://whitecollarprofessional.com/news-updates/kerala-high-court/registrar-cannot-decide-college-affiliation-conditional-affiliation-deemed-conti White Collar Professional en 2026-11-04T14:51:00.000Z Registrar Cannot Decide College Affiliation; Conditional Affiliation Deemed Continued Kerala University affiliation, Registrar jurisdiction, deemed continuation of affiliation, conditional affiliation, BDS college affiliation https://whitecollarprofessional.com/news-updates/karnataka-high-court/enhancement-of-compensation-awarded-to-deceaseds-dependents-and-rejection-of-tra White Collar Professional en 2026-11-02T15:03:00.000Z Enhancement of Compensation Awarded to Deceased's Dependents and Rejection of Transport Corporation's Appeal Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 - Section 173(1), Rash and negligent driving, Third-party claim, KSRTC liable for compensation https://whitecollarprofessional.com/news-updates/bombay-high-court/nominal-shop-occupants-cannot-claim-ordinary-membership-without-title-or-a-valid White Collar Professional en 2026-11-04T14:42:00.000Z Nominal Shop Occupants Cannot Claim Ordinary Membership Without Title or a Valid Membership Application Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, nominal membership, ordinary membership, Section 154B-7, Section 23(2) MCS Act https://whitecollarprofessional.com/news-updates/karnataka-high-court/high-court-permits-conversion-of-writ-petition-into-commercial-appeal-under-sect White Collar Professional en 2026-11-05T15:12:00.000Z High Court Permits Conversion of Writ Petition into Commercial Appeal Under Section 37 Commercial Courts Act Commercial Courts Act, 2015, Section 37, Writ Petition, Maintainability, Conversion to Commercial Appeal https://whitecollarprofessional.com/news-updates/orissa-high-court/covid-19-hardship-justified-condonation-of-delay-in-filing-form-10b-audit-report White Collar Professional en 2026-11-03T14:58:00.000Z COVID-19 Hardship Justified Condonation of Delay in Filing Form 10B Audit Report Form 10B audit report, Section 119(2)(b) Income Tax Act, condonation of delay, Section 12A exemption, COVID-19 genuine hardship https://whitecollarprofessional.com/news-updates/madras-high-court/high-court-grants-suspension-of-sentence-in-section-307-ipc-conviction-consideri White Collar Professional en 2026-11-03T15:18:00.000Z High Court Grants Suspension of Sentence in Section 307 IPC Conviction Considering Four Years Incarceration suspension of sentence, Section 307 IPC, Section 430 Bnss, Madras High Court bail, incarceration period bail https://whitecollarprofessional.com/news-updates/supreme-court-of-india/supreme-court-restores-acquittal-where-dying-declarations-conflict White Collar Professional en 2026-11-05T15:37:00.000Z Supreme Court Restores Acquittal Where Dying Declarations Conflict benefit of doubt, Supreme Court criminal appeal, Section 302 IPC, burden of proof prosecution, appeal against acquittal, Section 106 Evidence Act, conflicting dying declaration https://whitecollarprofessional.com/news-updates/supreme-court-of-india/supreme-court-counts-detention-from-actual-loss-of-liberty-for-24-hour-rule White Collar Professional en 2026-11-05T10:01:00.000Z Supreme Court Counts Detention from Actual Loss of Liberty for 24-Hour Rule NDPS Act arrest procedure, Article 22(2) Constitution, magistrate remand safeguards, Section 58 BNSS, actual time of detention, 24 hour arrest detention rule https://whitecollarprofessional.com/news-updates/supreme-court-of-india/supreme-court-requires-recording-of-plaint-rejections-before-suit-registration White Collar Professional en 2026-11-05T09:56:00.000Z Supreme Court Requires Recording of Plaint Rejections Before Suit Registration unnumbered plaint rejection, Supreme Court civil procedure, Section 122 CPC, Order IV Rule 2 register, rejection of plaint before registration, Order VII Rule 11 CPC https://whitecollarprofessional.com/news-updates/supreme-court-of-india/supreme-court-upholds-original-tenure-holders-rights-in-consolidation-allotment- White Collar Professional en 2026-11-05T09:51:00.000Z Supreme Court Upholds Original Tenure Holders’ Rights in Consolidation Allotment Dispute Consolidation of Holdings Act, roadside land allotment, original tenure holders, Plot 159 Basti dispute, Uttar Pradesh land consolidation https://whitecollarprofessional.com/news-updates/insolvency-bankruptcy-board/ibbi-rejects-rti-appeal-seeking-collated-disciplinary-committee-orders White Collar Professional en 2026-11-03T09:46:00.000Z IBBI Rejects RTI Appeal Seeking Collated Disciplinary Committee Orders Aditya Bandopadhyay judgment, existing public authority records, IBC Section 197, Section 19 RTI appeal, Section 2(f) RTI Act, Disciplinary Committee constitution, IBBI RTI appeal