The Division Bench dismissed the connected writ appeals, while making a limited modification to the Single Judge’s findings concerning the Bar Council of Kerala. In light of…
Bombay High Court on Exclusive Ownership under Bombay Tenancy Act: Civil Suit for Partition Not Maintainable.
Update / Judgement Date
12 Nov 2025
Source
WCP News Bulletin
Author
Sakshi Bhardwaj — WCP Legal Desk
Reading Time
3 min read
View Count
1

The Bombay High Court held that once ownership of agricultural land is conferred under Sections 32G and 32M of the Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, 1948, such ownership becomes exclusive and cannot be reopened through a civil suit for partition. The Court ruled that the civil court lacked jurisdiction under Sections 85 and 85-A of the Act, and the claim was also barred by limitation. Consequently, the Second Appeal filed by the appellant was allowed, and the judgments of the Trial Court and the District Court were set aside.
• The dispute pertained to agricultural lands situated in Uran, Raigad, Maharashtra (Survey Nos. 21, 22, and 29/1).
• The original tenant, Ramji Patil, died in 1949, and his wife Yenibai/Venibai was recorded as the protected tenant in 1952.
• Around 1957, Krishnabai (Appellant) was recorded as the kul (tenant), and in 1961, she acquired ownership through proceedings under Sections 32G and 32M of the Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, receiving a Sale Certificate in her name.
• In 2002, Savitribai (Respondent), her sister, filed a civil suit for partition, claiming the land was joint family property.
• The Trial Court decreed partition, and the District Court dismissed Krishnabai’s appeal. Hence, the present Second Appeal was filed before the High Court.
• The ownership was validly conferred upon Krishnabai in 1961 through a proper 32G and 32M process, and the Sale Certificate (Exhibit 38) conclusively established her title.
• There was no evidence that Krishnabai acted as a representative of the family or that the land was cultivated jointly.
• The respondents never challenged the 32G and 32M proceedings, the mutation entry, or the sale certificate for more than four decades, making their claim hopelessly delayed.
• The decision relied upon by the respondents, Ramakant Ganesh Naik v. Anusaya Shantaram Naik (2024 (3) Mh.L.J. 389), was found inapplicable, as in that case there was proof of joint cultivation, unlike here.
• The High Court emphasized that Sections 85 and 85-A of the Tenancy Act bar civil courts from reopening tenancy issues, which must be adjudicated exclusively by revenue authorities.
• The suit, filed in 2002, was therefore barred by limitation and beyond civil court jurisdiction.
• Ownership of the disputed land vested exclusively in the appellant, Krishnabai, in 1961 under Section 32M.
Legal Provisions Discussed: