The Division Bench dismissed the connected writ appeals, while making a limited modification to the Single Judge’s findings concerning the Bar Council of Kerala. In light of…
Delhi High Court: Eviction Order Passed in Favour of Landlord; Bona Fide Requirement for Son Upheld.
Update / Judgement Date
11 Nov 2025
Source
WCP News Bulletin
Author
Sakshi Bhardwaj — WCP Legal Desk
Reading Time
4 min read
View Count
2

The Delhi High Court set aside the Rent Controller’s order granting leave to defend to the tenant and upheld the landlord’s bona fide requirement for eviction under Section 14(1)(e) read with Section 25B of the Delhi Rent Control Act, 1958. The Court held that the landlord’s need to reclaim the shop for his unemployed married son to start an independent business was genuine, and the tenant failed to raise any substantial triable issue. It further ruled that the property, situated in Babarpur (Village Maujpur), fell within an urbanized area, making the Delhi Rent Control Act applicable.
• The petitioner, Hemant Gupta (landlord), filed an eviction petition under Section 14(1)(e) of the DRC Act for Shop No. 2, Ground Floor, Property No. 20-E/1, Babarpur Main Road, Shahdara, Delhi, claiming bona fide need for his unemployed married son, Yashasvi, to start a general store.
• The premises were originally let out in 1984 by the previous owner, and the petitioner became the owner via a registered sale deed dated 26 September 2006.
• The tenant, Ishwar Chand, filed an application for leave to defend, contending that:
- The DRC Act was inapplicable to the area.
- The landlord’s son was already employed, running a business under the name M/s Akansha Generators.
- The landlord possessed sufficient alternative accommodations.
- • The Rent Controller (ARC) allowed the tenant’s leave to defend on 24 May 2024, holding that the landlord failed to establish bona fide need and that applicability of the DRC Act was uncertain.
- • Aggrieved, the landlord filed the present revision petition before the High Court.
• Maintainability: The Court rejected the tenant’s objection on maintainability, citing precedents (R.S. Bakshi v. H.K. Malhari; Prem Lata v. Pawan Kumar Khurana).
• Bona Fide Requirement:
- The landlord’s claim that his married son required the shop for starting an independent business was credible and genuine.
- Photographs and claims that the son was “already employed” at M/s Akansha Generators were insufficient to rebut the presumption of bona fide need.
- The GST registration certificate produced by the landlord established that he himself, not his son, was the proprietor of M/s Akansha Generators.
- The Court reiterated that under and , a landlord’s assertion of genuine requirement is presumed true, subject to strong rebuttal by the tenant.