The Division Bench dismissed the connected writ appeals, while making a limited modification to the Single Judge’s findings concerning the Bar Council of Kerala. In light of…
Delhi High Court on Proof and Validity of a Will: Testamentary Jurisdiction and Suspicious Circumstances.
Update / Judgement Date
28 Oct 2025
Source
WCP News Bulletin
Author
Sakshi Bhardwaj — WCP Legal Desk
Reading Time
4 min read
View Count
2

The Delhi High Court dismissed an appeal challenging the grant of probate of a Will executed by late R.N. Gupta, upholding the findings of the Single Judge that the Will was genuine and duly executed. The Court reiterated that a Probate Court’s jurisdiction is limited to determining the genuineness and due execution of a Will, and it cannot adjudicate property disputes or the validity of family settlements. Alleged “suspicious circumstances” must be substantiated by cogent evidence.
• The deceased, R.N. Gupta (RNG), passed away on 14.02.2006, leaving behind his wife Raj Gupta and three children — Meera Sawhney (Appellant No.1), Gargi Gupta (Appellant No.2), and Bharat Gupta (Respondent No.2).
• Through a Memorandum of Family Settlement (MOFS) dated 01.04.1999, RNG received a 1/5th share in an undivided property — Bungalow No. 4, University Road, Delhi.
• He executed a registered Will dated 17.09.2000, bequeathing his movable and immovable properties, including his share in the undivided property, to his wife, excluding his children during her lifetime.
• After RNG’s death, his son Bharat Gupta (Respondent No.2) filed a Probate Petition as executor of the Will. The daughters (Appellants) contested the petition alleging suspicious circumstances and invalidity of the Will.
• The learned Single Judge, after examining evidence, allowed the probate on 20.02.2023. The daughters appealed.
• A civil suit for partition of the HUF property and another for appointment of Karta were pending, hence the Will’s subject matter was sub judice.
• The MOFS was invalid since it was unregistered and unsigned by all coparceners; thus, RNG could not have bequeathed the property.
• The Will suffered from five suspicious circumstances:
- It surfaced after six years of execution.
- The son (executor) was allegedly disinherited.
- Discrepancies existed in property descriptions.
- The mutual Will of Raj Gupta was concealed until RNG’s death.
- The Will was vague and coercive.
- • The Single Judge exceeded testamentary jurisdiction by commenting on the validity of the MOFS.
• RNG executed the Will in sound mental and physical health; attesting witnesses (Adv. Mukta Kapoor and Adv. Anupama Kaul) confirmed he read and signed it voluntarily.
• The Armchair Rule supports that the Will reflected a natural, reasoned disposition.
Court’s Observations:Legal Principles Discussed:Conclusion / Decision