The Division Bench dismissed the connected writ appeals, while making a limited modification to the Single Judge’s findings concerning the Bar Council of Kerala. In light of…
Delhi High Court on Video-Conferencing Examination in Official Secrets Act Case.
Update / Judgement Date
28 Oct 2025
Source
WCP News Bulletin
Author
Sakshi Bhardwaj — WCP Legal Desk
Reading Time
4 min read
View Count
1

The Delhi High Court set aside the Trial Court’s order refusing to allow the examination of witness Mr. C. Edmonds Allen through video-conferencing in a case under the Official Secrets Act, 1923 (OSA). The Court held that the Delhi High Court Video Conferencing Rules, 2020 are facilitative, not restrictive, and that the consent of the accused under Rule 5.3.11 cannot act as an absolute bar.
Invoking Rule 18, the Court relaxed this requirement and permitted video-conferencing testimony from the Indian Consulate, New York, with stringent safeguards to protect classified material.
- The CBI registered RC AC-1/2012/A0012 on 28 August 2012 under Section 3, OSA, read with Section 120-B IPC, alleging that Abhishek Verma, Anca Maria Neacsu, and others had obtained and transmitted classified defence documents to unauthorised persons, including C. Edmonds Allen.
- The FIR was based on Allen’s letter dated 6 June 2012 to the Defence Minister, enclosing sensitive material later found to be classified.
- The CBI sought to examine Allen (PW-46) via video-conferencing due to his residence in the U.S. and health issues.
- The Trial Court dismissed the application (6 April 2023), reasoning that providing copies of classified documents to a witness abroad would violate the OSA and that the accused’s consent for video-conferencing was mandatory.
- The CBI challenged this order under Section 482 CrPC.
- Purpose of Rule 5.3.11: The rule ensures fairness to the accused but does not confer a veto power preventing the examination of witnesses.
- Rule 18 Relaxation: The High Court has the authority to relax procedural requirements where rigid application would impede justice.
- Video-Conferencing as Valid Evidence: Following State of Maharashtra v. Dr Praful B. Desai (2003 4 SCC 601) and Manju Devi v. State of Rajasthan (2019 6 SCC 203), evidence recorded by video-conference satisfies Section 273 CrPC.
- OSA Concerns: The OSA does not prohibit video-conferencing; secrecy can be maintained through in-camera proceedings and restricted access.
- Safeguards Over Prohibition: Risk of information leakage must be managed, not used to deny evidence. Secure in-camera proceedings, court-controlled feeds, and redacted copies can adequately preserve confidentiality.
- Material Witness: Allen’s testimony is essential to prove the chain of custody and authenticity of the documents forming the core of the prosecution case.