The Division Bench dismissed the connected writ appeals, while making a limited modification to the Single Judge’s findings concerning the Bar Council of Kerala. In light of…
Income Tax Appellate Tribunal on Capital Gains: Gift of Shares Must Be Accepted When Supported by Evidence
Update / Judgement Date
24 Nov 2025
Source
WCP News Bulletin
Author
Sakshi Bhardwaj — WCP Legal Desk
Reading Time
3 min read
View Count
2

The ITAT Delhi upheld the CIT(A)’s decision deleting an addition of ₹15.84 crore, holding that the Assessing Officer (AO) wrongly treated the assessee’s sale of shares as short-term capital gain and incorrectly denied deduction under Section 54F. The Tribunal agreed that crucial shares were received as a gift, not purchased, and the AO had rejected valid documentary evidence without proper inquiry. Once supported by a gift deed, affidavits, demat statements, and corroborated share-movement records, the gift had to be accepted. As the donor held the shares for over 24 months, the assessee’s gains were long-term, making Section 54F deduction allowable.
- The assessee sold 6,51,000 shares of Viney Corporation Pvt. Ltd.
The AO held that the assessee’s father, Shri Viney Prakash Agarwal, had purchased 9,23,826 shares from Smt. Sudesh Kumari on 02.07.2019, and subsequently gifted part of them to the assessee in October 2020.
Based on this, the AO:
treated the shares as short-term capital assets,
computed short-term capital gain,
denied Section 54F deduction, and
added ₹15,84,78,027 to the income.
The assessee argued that the AO misread documents—the shares were not purchased but gifted, supported by:
a gift deed (02.07.2019) executed by Sudesh Kumari,
affidavit of the donor,
demat account transfer records, and
VCL share-movement statements.
CIT(A) accepted the evidence and deleted the addition.
Revenue appealed.
- AO doubted the gift deed merely on suspicion, claiming it was created after the show-cause notice.
- However, he failed to investigate or bring contrary evidence.
- The donor’s sworn affidavit was ignored without justification, contrary to Supreme Court ruling in Daulat Ram Rawatmull (1973) 87 ITR 349 that affidavits must be accepted unless disproved through inquiry.
- Documents showed Sudesh Kumari owned 24,46,590 shares before 31.03.2016, and gifted 9,23,826 shares to Viney Prakash Agarwal.
- Demat transfers substantiated the gift.
- In the remand report, the AO himself admitted that the only difference in the new documents was and —no adverse finding was made.