The Division Bench dismissed the connected writ appeals, while making a limited modification to the Single Judge’s findings concerning the Bar Council of Kerala. In light of…
SC: Additional Recommendation for Stamp Duty Exemption is Illegal & Superfluous.
Update / Judgement Date
04 Dec 2025
Source
WCP News Bulletin
Author
Sakshi Bhardwaj — WCP Legal Desk
Reading Time
4 min read
View Count
2

The Supreme Court held that the Memo dated 20.02.2009 issued by the Principal Secretary, Registration Department, Jharkhand—requiring a recommendation from the Assistant Registrar, Cooperative Society as a pre-condition for stamp duty exemption under Section 9A of the Indian Stamp (Bihar Amendment) Act, 1988—is illegal, unnecessary and based on irrelevant considerations.
The Court ruled that once a cooperative society is registered, the certificate of registration is conclusive evidence of its existence under Section 5(7) of the Jharkhand Self-Supporting Cooperative Societies Act, 1996. The added requirement imposed by the Memo is superfluous, impedes ease of transactions, and provides no value addition.
Consequently, the Supreme Court set aside the Jharkhand High Court judgment and struck down the Memo as arbitrary and unlawful.
• The appellant is a registered cooperative society engaged in providing housing and utilities to its members.
• Section 9A of the Stamp Act (Bihar Amendment) grants complete exemption from stamp duty for instruments relating to transfer of premises by cooperative societies to their members.
• In 2009, the Principal Secretary issued Memo No. 494 dated 20.02.2009, directing all District Sub-Registrars to grant exemption under Section 9A only on receipt of a recommendation from the Assistant Registrar, Cooperative Society.
• The appellant challenged the Memo, arguing that it creates an extra-statutory hurdle, violates statutory rights, and burdens cooperative societies with an unnecessary requirement.
• The Single Judge and Division Bench of the Jharkhand High Court upheld the Memo, leading to the appeal before the Supreme Court.
• Administrative decisions are invalid if they:
– fail to consider relevant factors, or
– consider irrelevant factors.
• Imposing extra, unnecessary requirements with no statutory backing is also a form of illegality, as it burdens citizens and disrupts good governance.
2. Nature & Purpose of Section 9A• Section 9A creates a statutory right: cooperative societies may transfer premises without stamp duty.
• It also creates a duty on registering authorities to register such documents without seeking additional compliance.
3. Memo’s Additional Requirement is IllegalThe Court found the Memo illegal because:
4. Irrelevant Consideration: “Preventing Fake Societies”5. High Court’s ErrorLegal Provisions Discussed:Decision: