The Division Bench dismissed the connected writ appeals, while making a limited modification to the Single Judge’s findings concerning the Bar Council of Kerala. In light of…
Supreme Court on Departmental Enquiry, Natural Justice, and Judicial Review.
Update / Judgement Date
27 Oct 2025
Source
WCP News Bulletin
Author
Sakshi Bhardwaj — WCP Legal Desk
Reading Time
3 min read
View Count

Headnote:
The Supreme Court restored the order of the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT) which had set aside the dismissal of a Travelling Ticket Examiner (TTE) on grounds of lack of evidence and violation of natural justice. The Court held that when the findings of a departmental enquiry are perverse and unsupported by evidence, judicial review is justified. The High Court erred in reversing the well-reasoned decision of the CAT.
Background:
• The appellant was serving as a TTE in Central Railway, Nagpur. On 31.05.1988, a vigilance check led to allegations of demanding illegal gratification from passengers, possessing excess undeclared cash, failing to recover fare difference, and forging a duty card pass.
• A charge sheet was issued on 03.07.1989 under the Railway Services (Conduct) Rules, 1966, and after enquiry, he was dismissed from service on 07.06.1996.
• The CAT, Mumbai Bench, set aside the dismissal on 21.03.2002, holding that the charges were unproved and directing reinstatement with all consequential benefits.
• The Bombay High Court (Nagpur Bench), by judgment dated 21.09.2017, reversed the CAT’s order and upheld the dismissal.
• During pendency of proceedings, the appellant died, and his legal heirs pursued the matter before the Supreme Court.
Court’s Observations:
• The main complainant, Hemant Kumar, whose statement formed the basis of the bribery charge, was never examined, depriving the appellant of cross-examination and violating fair hearing principles.
• Other passengers, Dinesh Choudhary and Rajkumar Jaiswal, did not support the bribery allegation, and their statements were misinterpreted.
• Possession of ₹1254/- was not misconduct since no rule prescribed a cash limit for TTEs, and the amount was duly deposited in Railway Sundry Accounts.
• The charge of failing to recover ₹18/- from a passenger was unsubstantiated; relevant receipts and witnesses were not produced.
• The forgery charge relating to the duty card pass remained unproved as no handwriting expert opinion was obtained.
• CAT was justified in finding that the enquiry findings were perverse and unsupported by evidence.
• The High Court failed to recognize that judicial review can be exercised when disciplinary findings are based on no evidence.