The Division Bench dismissed the connected writ appeals, while making a limited modification to the Single Judge’s findings concerning the Bar Council of Kerala. In light of…
Update / Judgement Date
17 Dec 2025
Source
WCP News Bulletin
Author
Sakshi Bhardwaj — WCP Legal Desk
Reading Time
3 min read
View Count
1

The Supreme Court set aside the conviction of a doctor for rape under Section 376(2)(d) IPC, holding that when the victim and her husband turn hostile and do not support the prosecution case, conviction cannot be sustained merely on the basis of the FIR, investigating officer’s testimony, or uncorroborated circumstantial evidence. The Court emphasized that presuming witnesses were “won over” without evidence is impermissible and that hostile testimony, unsupported by reliable medical or forensic corroboration, cannot form the basis of conviction.
• The appellant, a medical practitioner, was accused of committing rape on a patient during examination at his clinic in Himmatnagar, Gujarat on 08.05.2001.
• An FIR was lodged on the basis of the victim’s allegations. After investigation, a charge-sheet was filed under Section 376(2)(d) IPC.
• The Trial Court convicted the appellant and sentenced him to six years’ rigorous imprisonment.
• On appeal, the Gujarat High Court dismissed the accused’s appeal and enhanced the sentence to ten years’ rigorous imprisonment on the State’s appeal.
• Aggrieved, the accused approached the Supreme Court.
• The victim (PW-1) and her husband (PW-2), the most material witnesses, did not support the prosecution case during trial and were declared hostile.
• Courts must be slow to rely on testimony of hostile witnesses unless corroborated by reliable independent evidence.
• The High Court erred in presuming, without evidence, that the victim and her husband were “won over” by the accused.
• Conviction cannot be based on the FIR or statements recorded during investigation when the same are not proved through substantive evidence at trial.
• Panch witnesses to recovery of clothes turned hostile and stated that their signatures were obtained on prepared documents at the instance of police.
• Medical evidence did not support recent sexual intercourse; no injuries were found on the victim’s private parts and semen was not detected during medical examination.
• Non-examination of independent witnesses present at the clinic further weakened the prosecution case.
• The prosecution failed to prove the charge beyond reasonable doubt.
• The Supreme Court allowed the appeals.
• The conviction and sentence imposed by the Trial Court and affirmed by the High Court were quashed and set aside.
• The appellant was acquitted of all charges, and bail bonds stood discharged.
• Section 376(2)(d), Indian Penal Code, 1860 – Rape by a person in a position of trust or authority.
• Section 313, Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – Examination of accused.
• Principles governing appreciation of evidence of hostile witnesses.
• Evidentiary value of FIR and investigation-stage statements.
Citation: 2025 INSC 1443
Case: Jayantibhai Chaturbhai Patel v. State of Gujarat
Court: Supreme Court of India
Bench: Justice Sanjay Karol & Justice Vipul M. Pancholi
Date of Decision: 16 December 2025
Criminal Appeal Nos.: 890–891 of 2017
© 2026 White Collar Professional Technologies Pvt. Ltd. All rights reserved. CIN: U74999MH2024PTC000001
The Division Bench dismissed the connected writ appeals, while making a limited modification to the Single Judge’s findings concerning the Bar Council of Kerala. In light of…
The High Court held that the trial court was not justified in directing the parties to undergo fresh DNA testing when the existing expert report had not been rejected for legally…
The High Court held that a subsequently communicated minimum 20% local-content requirement, including an indigenously developed EMS software condition, could not be…
The Division Bench held that the petitioner had been deprived of a reasonable opportunity to present its case before the Commissioner of Sales Tax. An adjournment request must be…
The High Court exercised its inherent jurisdiction to quash a POCSO FIR and the pending trial after obtaining independent reports verifying the parties’ marriage, family…
The Division Bench held that the writ court had exceeded the proper scope of the dispute between the supplier and KSBCL by deciding, in effect, the Revenue’s separate tax…
The High Court considered the petitioners’ request for regular bail in an Enforcement Directorate prosecution alleging money laundering under the Prevention of Money Laundering…
The High Court upheld the appellant’s conviction under Section 18 c of the NDPS Act for possession of opium but reduced the sentence of seven years’ rigorous imprisonment to the…
The High Court dismissed the State’s appeal against acquittal, holding that the trial court’s view was a reasonably possible view on the evidence and that material inconsistencies…
Renesas Design India Pvt. Ltd., a loss-making wholly owned subsidiary engaged in semiconductor design, and its parent Renesas Electronics India Pvt. Ltd. sought sanction of a…