HC Must Say Why State Police Investigation Is Unfair Before Ordering CBI Probe : Supreme Court Sets Aside Calcutta HC Order

The Supreme Court set aside a High Court direction for a CBI probe, citing a lack of reasons explaining why the state investigation was deemed unfair. The ruling emphasized the necessity for clear and compelling reasons when transferring cases to central investigative agencies. The Court highlighted that such decisions should not be made lightly and must be supported by substantial evidence indicating bias or inadequacy in the state investigation. This judgment reinforces the principle of judicial accountability and the need for transparency in the decision-making process.