The Division Bench dismissed the connected writ appeals, while making a limited modification to the Single Judge’s findings concerning the Bar Council of Kerala. In light of…
Supreme Court on Counter Claim Against Co-Defendant: Not Maintainable.
Update / Judgement Date
11 Nov 2025
Source
WCP News Bulletin
Author
Sakshi Bhardwaj — WCP Legal Desk
Reading Time
4 min read
View Count
1

The Supreme Court held that a counter claim cannot be maintained against a co-defendant in a civil suit, reaffirming the settled position under Order VIII Rule 6A of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC). The Court allowed the appeal filed by the plaintiff, setting aside concurrent orders of the Trial Court and the High Court that had permitted defendants No. 2 and 3—impleaded later—to raise a counter claim against the original defendant. The Court observed that the counter claim was barred by limitation, lacked a valid cause of action, and was impermissible in law since it was directed not against the plaintiff but a co-defendant.
• The appellant–plaintiff filed a suit for specific performance against Defendant No. 1 concerning 0.93 acres of land based on an oral agreement dated 2 December 2002.
• The plaintiff claimed that the entire consideration was paid on 3 December 2002 and possession delivered.
• Defendant No. 1 contended that two other persons (later Defendants No. 2 and 3) were already in possession of a part of the property, having entered into a separate agreement to purchase 50 decimals on 1 December 2002 for ₹2,95,000.
• The Trial Court allowed Defendants No. 2 and 3 to be impleaded and admitted their counter claim against Defendant No. 1 for transfer of the entire land.
• The High Court, invoking Article 227, refused to interfere, citing avoidance of multiplicity of litigation.
• Aggrieved, the plaintiff approached the Supreme Court.
• Counter Claim Against Co-Defendant Impermissible:
Referring to Rohit Singh v. State of Bihar [(2006) 12 SCC 734] and Rajul Mano Shah v. Kiranbhai Patel [(2025) 10 SCR 152], the Court reiterated that a counter claim under Order VIII Rule 6A CPC must be directed only against the plaintiff, not against another defendant.
• Lack of Concrete Cause of Action:
Defendants No. 2 and 3 failed to prove readiness and willingness to pay the remaining consideration. Their claim was vague and inconsistent—admitting that 43 decimals had already been sold to the plaintiff’s father while alleging fraud in the measurement (43 changed to 93 decimals).
• Limitation Bar:
Even if their claim were valid, the alleged agreement dated 2 December 2002 meant the limitation for specific performance had expired long before their impleadment in 2006. Hence, any counter claim was time-barred.
• No Liberty for Separate Suit:
Decision:Legal Provisions Discussed:Judgments Relied Upon: