“Your Reply Not Accepted" Is Not Enough: Madras HC sets aside GST Order for Mindless Dismissal of...

The Madras High Court has set aside a GST order for "mindless dismissal of taxpayer's submission," stating "your reply not accepted is not enough." The court emphasized that tax authorities must provide reasoned orders and cannot summarily reject a taxpayer's reply without proper consideration and explanation. A mere statement of non-acceptance is insufficient and violates the principles of natural justice. This ruling reinforces the importance of reasoned decision-making and fair play in tax adjudication processes, protecting taxpayers from arbitrary orders.