ITAT Mumbai Restricts "Bogus Purchase" Addition to 3% Profit Margin, Upholds Principle of Consistency in Bhanwarlal Jain Group Case
Court / Authority
Income Tax Tribunal
Update / Judgement Date
27 Jun 2026
Source
WCP News Bulletin
Author
Manas Yadav — WCP Legal Desk
Reading Time
2 min read
View Count
5

Background
The Mumbai “D” Bench of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal has partly allowed the appeal filed by D.G. Exports for Assessment Year 2011–12, holding that where corresponding sales are accepted and stock records are not disputed, disallowance on account of alleged bogus purchases cannot be made in entirety and must be restricted to the profit element embedded in such transactions.
Entire purchases cannot be added when sales are accepted
The assessee, engaged in the business of trading in cut and polished diamonds, had its assessment reopened on the basis of information from the Investigation Wing alleging accommodation entries from the Bhanwarlal Jain Group. The Assessing Officer treated purchases amounting to ₹4.06 crore as bogus and added the entire amount to income under sections 147 read with 143(3). This action was affirmed by the NFAC Commissioner (Appeals), primarily relying on the investigation findings regarding the supplier entities being shell concerns.
Before the Tribunal, the assessee contended that the Assessing Officer had accepted corresponding sales, stock registers, and trading results, and had not recorded any adverse finding regarding availability of stock or suppression of sales. It was argued that in such circumstances, taxing the entire purchase value would lead to absurd results and only the profit component, if any, could be brought to tax.
The Tribunal's Decision
The ITAT Bench, comprising Judicial Member Shri Amit Shukla and Accountant Member Shri Vikram Singh Yadav, ruled in favor of the assessee.
The Tribunal noted that the Revenue Department could not dispute that the facts of the current case were pari-materia (identical) to the assessee’s other assessment years where only a 3% profit margin was taxed.
The Bench held that since the AO had not disputed the corresponding sales or the stock register, there was no justifiable reason to deviate from the position taken in other years for the same suppliers. Applying the Principle of Consistency, the Tribunal stated:
"...we find no justifiable reason in the findings of the AO which force him to deviate from his own position in other assessment years... more so where in terms of the availability of stock and corresponding sales, no adverse finding has been recorded by him."
The ITAT directed the AO to tax only 3% of the value of the impugned purchase transactions as the embedded profit margin and deleted the remaining addition of the entire purchase value.
Full Judgement / Attachment
Full Judgement
Frequently asked questions about Income Tax Tribunal
- What is the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT)?
- The ITAT, set up in 1941, is the second appellate authority in direct tax matters and the final fact-finding body. It hears appeals against orders of the Commissioner (Appeals) and certain other authorities, through benches across India.
- What is the time limit to file an appeal before the ITAT?
- An appeal must be filed within two months from the end of the month in which the order is communicated. This rule has applied since 1 October 2024 and continues under the Income-tax Act, 2025. The Tribunal can condone delay for sufficient cause.
- Can the ITAT stay a tax demand?
- Yes. The Tribunal can stay recovery of a disputed demand while an appeal is pending, usually on deposit of a part of the demand or furnishing security. Stays are granted for a limited period, and the appeal is expected to be decided within it.
- Where does an appeal go after the ITAT?
- An appeal against an ITAT order lies to the High Court, but only on a substantial question of law. A further appeal lies to the Supreme Court.
- How can White Collar Professional help with a ITAT matter?
- Post your requirement on White Collar Professional to receive proposals from verified Chartered Accountants and tax Advocates, compare them, and pay securely through the platform. This page also tracks the latest ITAT ITAT orders as they are reported.